BLOG

Kicking away the ladder – Climate rhetoric vs. agricultural reality at COP31

17 November 20262 min reading

In his 2002 seminal work Kicking Away the Ladder, Cambridge economist Ha-Joon Chang sparked widespread debate across economic and intellectual circles by arguing a striking thesis: developed nations industrialized through protectionist and interventionist policies, only to kick away the ladder they used to climb, preaching “free-market” orthodoxy to developing countries.

Looking at the rhetoric echoing from COP31 in Antalya and similar climate platforms, I cannot help but ask whether another version of this historical mechanism is being restaged today.

The friction on the ground is stark. Speaking at the summit, Turkish Feed Manufacturers’ Association (TÜRKİYEMBİR) President Ülkü Karakuş pointed out that small-scale producers whose share in global emissions is negligible are unfairly targeted. Simultaneously, the European Union’s Deforestation Regulation (EUDR), which mandates proof that commodities like soy and palm oil are not linked to deforestation, has drawn fierce resistance even from European feed manufacturing associations over supply chain disruptions and food security risks.

Yet, there is an important nuance here: unlike in Chang’s historical analysis, today’s regulatory squeeze does not merely pit the developed West against the developing world; Western farmers are suffering from the exact same bureaucratic suffocation. So much so that we have all witnessed how energy and fertilizer cost shocks triggered by geopolitical tensions around the Strait of Hormuz have deeply rattled political balances in Washington, where agrarian constituencies hold considerable sway.

If both producers in developing nations and Western farmers alike are vocalizing their grievances against this rigid framework, whose agenda is this hurriedly imposed new order actually serving?

Articles in Editor Category